Mascara Maneater™

EH

Okay mascara, but does tug and pull lashes out and tends to be a drier formula

All-time favorite

I’ve tried many other mascaras but this one is my holy grail. I have naturally long, fine, eyelashes, and this mascara coats them so nicely without clumping. I love how you can really work with the formula and comb through to get the desired effect without it drying too fast and getting clumpy. Keeps my eyelashes nice and healthy and long too! PS I love the brown - it is darker than it looks in the pics and is just subtly more natural looking - especially on light skin.

Solid mascara choice

I like that this mascara only takes two coats and that it comes in brown! It flakes a little but not unbearable. My go to.

Good lengthening mascara

I really like this mascara! I got it in a sample and I love it. I think it is a very good lengthening mascara. I like to use this one and then a volumizing mascara.

Great volume

I generally love the Maneater Mascara. People have asked if I had extensions when I’m wearing it! My only issue is that it will sometimes run in the humidity in the climate where I live.

Beautiful Eyelashes

This is the best mascara you could buy. It's been my go too since tarte released it. Leaves my eyes popping, and I always get compliments!

This mascara fits its name, it eats!

Of all the mascaras over all the years I’ve been wearing makeup, this is hands down my favorite. Goes on smooth and not clumpy, the brush is perfect & even gets the tiny lashes in the corners!

Awesome stuff

Awesome mascara, I have been using it for years and years. Always reliable for making my lashes look fuller and longer, even if it's just a swipe or two that I put on quickly to look a little more put together and awake!

One of my favorites

I love this mascara! It is a little pricey, but I absolutely love this mascara, it works great and looks amazing. I really like that I last all day or longer.

Worth it

I find it to be the best mascara ever still. Not difficult to remove, fab volume. I leave my bag in the car and I find it gets clumpy quicker in the tube than it used to but I still love it

The best

This is my favorite mascara out of any brand. It's very light on the lashes and doesn't make them thick or clumpy, but gives lift and definition.

The only mascara to revive my baby lashes!

I have tiny ginger lashes (IYKYK), so they do me no favors without mascara. After many disappointing attempts with other brands (even other formulas from Tarte!), this mascara is the one I keep coming back to and have purchased many, many times. It never clumps or looks spidery, and it is such a deep, rich, black color that looks great regardless of how I do the rest of my eye makeup. The only drawback is that on a particularly oily or sweaty day, it may rub off a bit on my upper eyelids, but it's barely noticeable. Not enough to knock it down from five stars!